Skip to content
Sharon and her sisters in Winnipeg

Sharon Gubbay Helfer: Oral History and Dialogue Work in Montreal and Beyond

Oral History

59 Windsor Avenue

Listen to this Oral History

Description

Listen to Sharon Gubbay Helfer talk about her incredible career and life path, from her Masters in Comparative Education and PhD in Jewish Studies, to her oral history work with Concordia's Centre for Oral History and Digital Studies (COHDS) and her dialogue work with the Montreal Dialogue Group and the Compassionate Listening Project. Beyond outlining the steps on her path, in this oral history Sharon also discusses the inspirations and motivations for her work, the challenges and values she finds in dialogue and compassionate listening, and her relationship with Judaism and her Sephardic heritage. Sharon Gubbay Helfer is an oral historian and a scholar-practitioner of difficult dialogues, as well as a Research Associate with Concordia University's Centre for Oral History and Digital Studies (COHDS) and Concordia University's Institute for Canadian Jewish Studies.


Transcript


(0:00 - 1:42)

I'm the oldest of three girls, and we had the same parents, and we lived on the same house on 59 Windsor Avenue in Westmount. And we had completely different childhoods, you know. So the childhood that I had, for example, I didn't know about the Holocaust.


Whereas my next sister, Michelle, a year and a half younger than me, she was obsessed with the Holocaust, and she did so much reading about it. And that, as you know, completely passed me by. I was really, like in my first year of English literature at McGill, reading a play, it centered on the Holocaust, and I was reading this stuff in the McGill library.


Really felt sick and dizzy and whoa. So it was very complicated for me. I mean, the Jewish dimension, you know, it's sort of, with the perspective of time now, looking back, I can see things kind of differently.


I went to Boston school. I went to Westmount High. So what was it like? I don't know.


It was mixed. It was surely mixed. I mean, the Temple Emanuel was the place that my parents joined because their friends told them that would be the best one for them, probably.


But it was really, I mean, on the Jewish sort of dimension, for me, it took a while. The school I went to had a significant Jewish population, maybe a third of the kids were Jewish, but none of them had parents from Calcutta and Alexandria, and they, you know, they ate stuff that I didn't know was gefilte fish. I mean, we didn't have that stuff.


(1:42 - 2:50)

So I didn't really feel like part of it. But I ended up in 1975 in Papua New Guinea, and I spent a year there. That was a very, very interesting time for me.


And then coming back, what happened? One thing and another anyway. But eventually, I ended up back at school doing a master's in comparative education. So I did that, but then I was kind of recruited from there by a woman called Margaret Gillette, who was a really interesting woman at McGill.


She said, Oh, you know, come do a, you know, master's in comparative education, and we'll go to Papua New Guinea. And, you know, so yeah, you know, but in the course of that, those studies, it's just like, actually, Jack Jedwab came and gave us a course in the, we had a whole series on the education of minorities in Montreal. So then Jack Jedwab came to talk to us about the Jews in Montreal.


(2:50 - 4:58)

And he said, Well, you know, there's the Ashkenazim and the Sephardim. And he said, Well, you know, the Sephardim, they're very cultivated. And, you know, this is me.


I do belong. Oh, my goodness. And it was just like, just one of those little moments when suddenly, like the whole gates of history opened, and I was part of it.


So then I just thought, What am I doing here to go to the ends of the world to Papua New Guinea to, you know, get a topic for my thesis? Can't I look in my own backyard? And that's when I discovered the Jewish Public Library. Anyway, that plunged me. And then I got to meet David Rome, who became my unofficial advisor, and just, you know, gave me like a spiritual transmission.


So it was, it was my introduction. And from there, it became very clear to me that there was nothing for me left in Montreal, and I had to go to Israel. So to live forever, obviously.


So I went and to Woodges, to the Ulpan in Arad. So, and then Peter, we met in Arad, and we've ended up coming back here and married. And we had three sons.


And somewhere, I mean, pretty early, I made up my mind that I wanted those boys to be part of the community. And just by complete accident, I bumped into somebody from Westmount High, Jonathan Cohen. He told me this belongs to a synagogue, and I should come.


In a nutshell, I went there for services. I didn't know anything about Reconstructionism, what happened, nothing. But then what happened was that I started going the first times I would go, I was like in tears every time.


(4:58 - 6:25)

Stuck to see like a grandparent there with a parent and a new baby. Oh, I've been, I guess, missing this, and the family here, you know. So it was, you know, it was a good choice.


Then I started to feel unbearably uncomfortable, because I thought everybody else knew everything about the service, you know, all the words, you know, all the service. I didn't know anything. I'm an idiot.


How can I possibly mother my three sons? Jewishly, I don't know anything. So this led me to say, okay, I'll go back to school. So I ended up doing the thesis on that congregation, a Canadian experiment in Reconstructionism, and I talked to people, and my sort of inborn impulse to talk to people and record people just, you know, was out in full force.


And it enabled me to know something about the community that I was becoming part of. So it was good. But at the same time, I kind of realized that I had this impulse to dialogue quite strongly.


But, you know, I'm not in a position to do things about what's going on in Israel. But I live here in Quebec. And at that time, ‘94-95, there was a referendum in ‘95.


(6:25 - 6:51)

And there was a dialogue group called Dialogue Saint-Hilbert. In any case, I became involved with Dialogue Saint-Hilbert. And I do remember, just on the eve of the referendum, there was a meeting that Jack Wolofsky had at his place at Trout Lake in the Laurentians.


And you could literally cut the air with a knife. It was so tense. I'd never experienced that before.


(6:51 - 9:41)

And that path of dialogue has, again, continued to this day through a few steps. And yeah, I mean, it became clear to me that just Jewish studies, which was my PhD, was not really the place I needed to be, that it had to be something with dialogue. And I also had this impulse to interview.


And anyway, I managed to get a two-year postdoc at the University of Montreal. And so there's a guy called Patrice Brodeur there, who had something called a chair in Islam, globalization, and pluralism. And I heard him on the radio.


I thought he was awesome. I went to see him. And I said, you know, can I work here? And I got funded for a two-year postdoc.


And it was really, like, it was, I was the only Jewish person in that. It was a very, very great research environment. There was a lot of research, well, a bunch of researchers around the chair.


And there would be wonderful meetings. When things got tense was when there would be an Israeli invasion in Gaza. And I really couldn't hardly walk in there.


People were allergic to me. They just didn't want me around. And that was interesting for them dialogically, you know.


But anyway, it was overall, it was a really great experience. So after that, I did manage, you know, it's like, to understand that I did all this oral history, I could call myself an oral historian. And then there was a job advertised by Ellen Scheinberg at the Ontario Jewish Archives.


And she created this awesome project called the Small Jewish Communities of Ontario. She wanted an oral historian to talk to people who were still around, and who remembered what the life of the community was. That was my wonderful job to do.


So that was wonderful. And then I did become aware of the Oral History Centre at Concordia, really when it was starting, as a matter of fact, it was just starting, just just starting. But I was very taken with the Oral History Centre.


And it took a while, but eventually, then after all this, and also worked on a really interesting project from Laval University called the Intangible Religious Heritage of Quebec. And I did a study, I like I organized, structured and carried out the interviews for a study of the Spanish, the Spanish Portuguese as the oldest Synagogue in Canada. That was really, really fun and really, really interesting.


(9:41 - 11:09)

I also did one of St. Andrew and St. Paul Church. But anyway, then, so then the Oral History Centre organized this mega project on life stories of Montrealers displaced by wars, genocides and other major human rights violations. And it was the last year of the five year project, and they had some extra funding to sort of bring everything together.


And so I got to sit and listen to a couple hundred hours of testimony from those different communities. And sort of you tag the different you break it up into little pieces and tag the pieces. So it becomes a searchable database, where you can see video clips gathered by theme or by keyword or is really, really something.


And, and there was this thing called the Montreal dialogue group. But I did I was co president for a number of years there with different Palestinian women. And anyway, but so when I got to Concordia working on that project, and so my sort of, you know, major task was to process all this material, but as a post document to also make a contribution to something original.


(11:09 - 12:44)

So then I thought, okay, here I am. Now all these life stories of people who've been displaced. I've been working on the board at the Montreal dialogue group with Rana and Sana and Bassam.


But what do I know about their life stories? Life stories? I don't know anything about their life stories. So I said, you know, I really want, I would really like to do like a little pilot project, life stories of Palestinian Canadians. So I took a deep breath and I just said, okay, I just want to do this.


And I did. And it was amazing. Like I there were five people that I interviewed.


But among those five people, there was such a range. I mean, it was an amazing, amazing project and much more challenging for me than I thought it would be. Getting in close there, hearing things like the other thing that happened was the Erika Lehrer, who had started this thing called the Center for Ethnographic Research and Exhibition in the Aftermath of Violence.


She just started it at Concordia and she was looking for projects. So I said, like, can I work with this material and create like something? So she said, sure, you know, and so we created an online exhibit based on the testimony that I had recorded. And I worked with the curator there, Monica Patterson, who was wonderful and helpful and so on.


(12:44 - 14:32)

And I learned from the curators about, you know, a field of difficult knowledge and how do we exhibit material that is not the great beauty that everyone can go and worship in a museum, but is part of our society. But, you know, my truth can be difficult for you to hear. So we did it and we got, we created this exhibit together and we had a website launch that was family and friends website launch.


It was very, very moving because I didn't expect that. But it seems that having the institution, the university hosting my life story as a Palestinian is quite different from being at a protest with a placard and saying it's not right and so on. You know, and the people, it really meant so much to them.


So the final steps on my path there. After that, I had the dialogue group. One of the things that happened was it busted apart and I was persuaded to become the old president after that.


And stuff, so we continued to do things. But, you know, in my heart, I thought, what do we know about dialogue here? And that's when I heard about the Compassionate Listening Project and Leah Greenwood founded it. And I thought, wow, you know, she's saying that listening is a pre-dialogue skill and it doesn't come naturally.


(14:32 - 15:42)

So, I mean, it comes over all such good listeners until we're faced with somebody that pushes all our buttons and then we're just in a fog of emotion and we can't really hear anything. So, you know, how to handle that. So I thought that made a lot of sense and managed to bring Leah Green here to Montreal.


And sort of in the wake of that, a few years ago now, I knew that one of her major things was taking delegations to Israel, Palestine, West Bank, whatever you want to call it, the region. And the view being that if you're going to transform a landscape of contention and conflict into a landscape of collaboration, then all the different people on that landscape are going to have to be heard, but really heard and received as valid human beings and not bad guys and we're the good guys and you don't know anything and we know everything. So she had this conviction and she'd been taking delegations for like 20 years.


(15:42 - 16:49)

And when I heard that the delegation was going to be going and that they were going to be called listening to the peacemakers, then I said, okay, this is what I need. Like I just need to be fed by people in that very, very difficult situation who've chosen to make peace. How did they do it? So I went, you know, and it was really, really awesome.


I mean, it was the situation was worse than I thought it was, but the people who are doing these things, everybody came back like feeling hope because of what people are doing and continue to do. And so when I came back then, I decided, okay, this is really good. I want to go through the certification process and become a compassionate listening facilitator.


And so that's what I did. And I've started doing that. I've been in one workshop, I'm going to give another one.


And I just like, I guess, I feel aligned, like this is what I'm meant to be doing.


Disclaimer

Please note that the views and opinions expressed in these recordings are those of the interviewee alone and do not necessarily reflect the positions of the Montreal Jewish Museum, its staff, or its Board of Directors. These recordings are presented as personal recollections for historical and educational purposes. Individual accounts reflect the interviewee's personal perspective and lived experience, and have not been independently verified for factual accuracy.

These transcriptions and translations have been produced using automated transcription and translation tools, followed by human review. Despite this process, inaccuracies may remain. If you identify an error, please contact research@imjm.ca with the page link and your suggested correction.

Contact Us